Yes, exactly. When they work, they really work: The Stand, The Shining (both versions, though I prefer the Kubrick myself, even though I know SK likes the miniseries better), Carrie. But when they suck? Oh my. Any version of 'Salem's Lot, for instance. *retch*
Yep. I've never seen any version at all of Salem's Lot.
But crap like that is one reason why it probably isn't a good idea to make a film/miniseries/whatever of the Dark Tower series, no matter how much the idea makes me want to start scribbling out dream casts.
I do that with every SK book I read -- dream-casting. Started doing it with Salem's Lot when I was 21. :) (Interesting side note: I cast Elijah Wood as Mark Petrie, even though I had only seen him in The Good Son and hadn't seen him in anything else for about four years at the time. He was too old -- 16 by the time I was 21 -- but in my mind he was still 12; I didn't know how old he was!)
But, erm, yeah. My point was actually not off the subject. It was: D00d, they said LotR was unfilmable? The Dark Tower series would be REALLY unfilmable. There's no WAY it would ever come close to what the fans imagine when we read it. SK is one of the greatest novelists there has ever been, in any era, but his books don't cross media genres very well!
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
no subject
But crap like that is one reason why it probably isn't a good idea to make a film/miniseries/whatever of the Dark Tower series, no matter how much the idea makes me want to start scribbling out dream casts.
no subject
But, erm, yeah. My point was actually not off the subject. It was: D00d, they said LotR was unfilmable? The Dark Tower series would be REALLY unfilmable. There's no WAY it would ever come close to what the fans imagine when we read it. SK is one of the greatest novelists there has ever been, in any era, but his books don't cross media genres very well!
no subject
Of course, that's what they said about LOTR. But I think you're right.